Academic All-America Selections
* denotes Academic All-America® of the Year
| Year | Name | Sport | Team |
| 1967 | Bill Druckemiller | Men's Basketball | -- |
| 1970 | Charlie Claggett | Men's Basketball | -- |
| 1975 | Dennis Thome | Football | First Team |
| 1987 | Grant Jones * | Football | First Team |
| 1987 | Rob Burnett | Men's Swimming | First Team |
| 1987 | Kevin Locke | Men's Basketball | First Team |
| 1988 | Kevin Locke | Men's Basketball | First Team |
| 1988 | Tiffany Jeisel | Women's Swimming | Second Team |
| 1989 | Tim Bolsar | Football | Second Team |
| 1990 | Kathryn Pongonis | Volleyball | Second Team |
| 1992 | Dave DeWitt | Men's Swimming | First Team |
| 1993 | Dave DeWitt | Men's Swimming | First Team |
| 1994 | Tim Dunham | XC/Track & Field | Second Team |
| 1995 | Casey Chroust | Men's Basketball | Third Team |
| 1995 | Michelle Duffey | Women's Soccer | Third Team |
| 1996 | Kristin Goldthorpe | Women's Swimming | First Team |
| 1997 | Casey Chroust | Men's Basketball | First Team |
| 1997 | Kristin Goldthorpe * | Women's Swimming | First Team |
| 1997 | Kristin Beutler | Women's Soccer | First Team |
| 1998 | Jon Dunham | Football | First Team |
| 1999 | Matt Trumbull | Men's Swimming | Second Team |
| 1999 | Eric Nigh | XC/Track & Field | Second Team |
| 1999 | Jon Dunham | Football | First Team |
| 2000 | Joel Norton | Baseball | Third Team |
| 2000 | Aaron Cole | Men's Swimming | First Team |
| 2000 | Susie Bettcher | Cross Country | Second Team |
| 2001 | Brian Goldthorpe | Men's Swimming | First Team |
| 2001 | Charlie DeLacey | Men's Basketball | Second Team |
| 2001 | Susie Bettcher | Track & Field | First Team |
| 2001 | Susie Bettcher | Cross Country | Second Team |
| 2001 | Katie Sprague | Women's Swimming | Second Team |
| 2002 | Charlie DeLacey | Men's Basketball | Third Team |
| 2002 | Kate Flikkema | Women's Swimming | Second Team |
| 2004 | Adam Mandel | Baseball | Third Team |
| 2004 | Jill Boo | Women's Swimming | Second Team |
| 2004 | Lauren Clark | Women's Swimming | Third Team |
| 2004 | Melanie Cluss | XC/Track & Field | Second Team |
| 2004 | Julie Hufnagel | XC/Track & Field | Second Team |
| 2004 | Colleen Wirtz | Women's Soccer | Third Team |
| 2005 | Jill Boo | Women's Swimming | First Team |
| 2005 | Sarah Peck | Women's Swimming | First Team |
| 2005 | Colleen Wirtz | Women's Soccer | First Team |
| 2005 | Elaine Binkley | XC/Track & Field | First Team |
| 2006 | A.J. Jezierski | Baseball | Second Team |
| 2006 | Erin Coughlin | Women's Tennis | Third Team |
| 2006 | Elaine Binkley | XC/Track & Field | First Team |
| 2007 | Kristen Hohl | Women's Swimming | Second Team |
| 2007 | Elaine Binkley * | XC/Track & Field | First Team |
| 2008 | James Clear | Baseball | Second Team |
| 2008 | Michael Barnes | XC/Track & Field | Second Team |
| 2008 | Erin Gorsich | Women's Tennis | Third Team |
| 2008 | Kristen Hohl | Women's Swimming | First Team |
| 2008 | Sarah Ash | Women's Soccer | Second Team |
| 2009 | Justin Held | Baseball | Third Team |
| 2009 | Kristen Hohl * | Women's Swimming | First Team |
| 2009 | Michael Barnes | XC/Track & Field | First Team |
| 2009 | Peter Shorten | Men's Soccer | First Team |
| 2010 | Katie Navarre | XC/Track & Field | Second Team |
| 2011 | Katie Navarre | XC/Track & Field | First Team |
| 2011 | Andrea Karl | Women's Soccer | Third Team |
| 2011 | Nat Kell | Football | Second Team |
| 2012 | Carlos Maciel | Men's Swimming | Third Team |
| 2012 | Andrea Karl | Women's Soccer | First Team |
| 2012 | Nat Kell | Football | First Team |
| 2012 | Braden Layer | Football | Second Team |
| 2013 | Carlos Maciel | Men's Swimming | Second Team |
| 2013 | Spencer Fronk | Men's Swimming | Third Team |
